Thumbtack Numbers: Spam-Like Messages Misrepresent Our Businesses and Damage Customer Trust
Since Thumbtack Numbers were introduced, I've experienced a significant decline in customer response rates, hire rates, and earnings. Lead quality has also declined while lead costs have increased. In recent weeks, I've been lucky to turn 2 out of 10 leads into actual jobs, with lead expenses sometimes approaching the revenue those jobs generate.
My biggest concern is how Thumbtack Numbers have changed the entire communication experience and how our businesses are presented to potential customers.
Before Thumbtack Numbers
When a customer contacted four Pros, they received responses through the Thumbtack app. Each Pro could independently decide whether and when to follow up through direct SMS or phone calls.
If a customer responded through the app, the conversation could continue there. If both parties switched to SMS, they could communicate directly without unnecessary duplication between channels.
We controlled how we introduced our businesses, when we followed up, and how we presented our services.
After Thumbtack Numbers
Every in-app message is automatically mirrored through SMS using Thumbtack's virtual numbers.
When four or five Pros respond within seconds, customers can receive a flood of messages through both the app and SMS. This duplication continues throughout the conversation, rather than allowing both parties to simply communicate through their preferred channel.
Customers now see unfamiliar, often similar-looking virtual numbers instead of our actual business numbers. Standardized messages, automated instructions, and lengthy links can make professional communication look like mass-generated spam.
This creates unnecessary clutter and confusion, making it harder for customers to identify individual businesses, follow conversations, and choose whom to hire.
Phone calls are affected too.
Instead of connecting directly to a business, callers may have to listen to automated Thumbtack announcements, including call-recording notices, before speaking with the actual Pro.
Imagine calling a local painting or cleaning business and hearing an automated message mentioning an unrelated company before you can even speak to the business owner.
It interrupts the natural flow of communication, delays the connection, and can create confusion about who the customer is actually contacting.
For small businesses and self-employed professionals, answering calls quickly and personally is part of the service we provide. We don't need a third-party platform introducing itself or inserting corporate-style announcements into our customer conversations.
Our communication is part of our business identity.
The way we answer calls, introduce ourselves, write messages, follow up, and communicate with customers directly affects our professional image, customer trust, and hiring opportunities.
These are fundamental parts of running an independent business and competing with other service providers.
Thumbtack is a lead-generation platform. We pay it to connect us with potential customers, not to act as our business representative or control how we communicate after that connection is made.
Yet Thumbtack now determines significant parts of how our messages and phone calls are presented, without giving us meaningful control over that experience.
There needs to be a clear boundary between generating leads and interfering with how independent businesses communicate with their customers.
The financial consequences of poor communication, lost trust, and missed hiring opportunities fall on us, not on Thumbtack.
Whatever the intended benefits of Thumbtack Numbers, they should not come at the expense of our professional image, customer experience, and ability to run our businesses independently.
Thumbtack Numbers: Before vs. After
Issue | Before Thumbtack Numbers | After Thumbtack Numbers |
|---|---|---|
1. Lead Performance & Earnings | Higher response rates, hire rates, and more consistent earnings. | Significant decline in responses, hires, and earnings. Higher lead costs and lower perceived lead quality. |
2. Communication Channels | Pros and customers could choose between the app, direct SMS, or calls and continue in one preferred channel. | Messages are automatically mirrored between the app and SMS, regardless of the preferred channel. |
3. Message Flooding | Messages arrived through the chosen channel. Additional SMS follow-ups depended on each Pro's timing and decision. | Duplicate messages across both channels create notification overload throughout the hiring process, especially with multiple Pros. |
4. Sender Identification | Direct SMS and calls came from each Pro's actual phone number. | Unfamiliar, similar-looking virtual numbers make businesses harder to distinguish. |
5. Message Appearance | Short, personal, professionally written SMS controlled by each business. | Standardized messages with automated text, instructions, and links can appear spam-like. |
6. Phone Calls | Direct calls connected customers to the business without platform announcements. | Automated Thumbtack announcements and recording notices can delay calls and confuse business identity. |
7. Business Presentation | Pros controlled their introductions, offers, and first impressions. | Thumbtack influences how businesses are presented through messages and calls. |
8. Customer Experience | Clearer communication through the customer's preferred channel. | Duplicate notifications, similar-looking numbers, and automated messages can cause confusion and frustration. |
9. Competition & Differentiation | Pros could stand out through personalized communication, timing, and professionalism. | Standardized communication reduces individuality and makes businesses appear more similar. |
10. Business Independence | Thumbtack generated leads; Pros independently managed customer communication. | Thumbtack intervenes in communication, potentially affecting business image, trust, and hiring opportunities. |
Resources
- All Categories
- 1.5K Atlanta Pro Community
- 94 Pro AI Hub
- 977 New Pro Hub
- 5 PAB & PPC corner
- 541 Trending topics
- 227 Feedback in Action
- 89 Wins and Recognition
- 21 Tools to help grow & run your business
- Pro Mentorship
- 274 Comunidad en Español
- 3 Featured Events
- 506 On-Demand Webinars
- 207 Network and Collaborate
- 361 Thumbtack Pro Rewards
- 1.9K Business Resources
- 280 Inspiration
- 168 Business Resilience
- 340 Thumbtack Resources
- 670 Community News
Welcome! Check out our Community Code of Conduct. (review here)